Is Hills Natural Training Treats Really Worth It Now?

Have you ever looked for a snack that feels healthy but fun? If so, Hills Natural Training Treats may have caught your eye. I first saw them at my vet’s office. They used the treats as quick rewards after a checkup. That made me wonder—can one small treat mix taste, health, and trust? Over time, I found some good things about these snacks. But I also found a few flaws worth sharing. In this review, I’ll show you what makes them shine and where they could improve. That way, you can decide if they are right for your dog before you buy a bag.

My Personal Experience: Hill’s Natural Training Treats

I’ve been using Hill’s natural dog food and their soft training treats for over two years. My dogs have had mixed but mostly good results. What I like most is the balance of taste and nutrition. My pets enjoy them, and I trust the brand since vets back it. Over time, I’ve tried options like Hill’s Natural Training Soft & Chewy Treats. I also checked Hill’s Natural Balance dog food reviews to compare. For me, the steady quality and science-based approach make Hill’s stand out. Still, I’ve noticed a few small quirks.

Ingredients Analysis

The ingredient list tells the real story. Hill’s keeps it simple: Peanut Butter, Potatoes, Wheat Flour, Cane Molasses, Glycerin, Peanuts, Chicken Fat, Bananas, Peas, Pork Gelatin, Natural Flavors, Dried Skim Milk, Citric Acid, Lactic Acid, and Tocopherols for freshness.

My dogs love the peanut butter and banana mix. I also like that there are no fake preservatives. But the treats can get hard if not stored well. Compared to many brands, Hill’s offers flavor and health in one. To me, they feel more like a homemade snack than a factory-made biscuit.

Nutrient Analysis

I wanted to know what my dogs get from these snacks. On a dry matter basis, they have 17.6% protein, 19.5% fat, and 65.1% carbs. They also have fiber, vitamins, minerals, and Omega-3 and Omega-6 fatty acids for coat health.

From my view, these numbers show the treats are rewards, not full nutrition. They taste good and fill a gap, but they don’t replace meals. Some treats are just empty calories, but Hill’s gives a more balanced option. I still see them as extras, not a main food.

Key Features

What makes these treats stand out is the natural mix and soft feel. Hill’s Natural Soft Savories with Peanut Butter & Banana are sold as soft and chewy. They’re not always as soft as I’d like, but still easier to break than a hard biscuit.

I’ve used them as training rewards and quick snacks. My dogs always look forward to them. They fit well with Hill’s natural dog food for both puppies and adults. The only downside is the bag size. It feels small for the price, more so if you have more than one dog. Still, the brand trust and good quality help make up for it.

What I Like

Over the years, I’ve tried many treats with my dogs. Hill’s has kept a steady spot in our routine. I like how they mix taste with good nutrition. Not every bag is perfect, but the brand gives me more pros than cons. Here’s what stood out to me:

• Trusted Ingredients – Real peanut butter and bananas make these feel like “people food.” My dogs enjoy them more than plain biscuits.
• Vet-Backed Brand – Hill’s is vet-recommended, which gives me peace of mind. I trust it more than random store treats.
• Easy for Training – Hill’s Natural Training Soft & Chewy Treats are small. They break up easily, so I can reward them often without overfeeding.
• Consistency Across Products – From treats to Hill’s Natural Dog Food to Hill’s Natural Balance Dog Food, the science-based feel stays the same.
• Digestibility – My sensitive pup has fewer tummy upsets with these. That makes a big difference.
• Taste Appeal – Even my picky eater looks forward to them. That’s not always true with “healthy” snacks.
• Good Variety – Peanut butter and banana are a favorite, but the other flavors keep things fun.

Feeding Tips

Treats need balance. I’ve learned that “just one more” can add too many calories fast. With Hill’s, I stick to their guide. It keeps my dogs at a good weight.

• Feed as a snack or reward, not a meal.
• Treats should be no more than 10% of daily calories.
• For freshness, use within 3 weeks. I store mine in a sealed jar so they don’t harden.

Hill’s daily feeding guide:

• 5 lbs → 1 treat
• 10 lbs → 1 treat
• 20 lbs → 2 treats
• 30 lbs → 3 treats
• 40 lbs → 4 treats
• 50 lbs → 4 treats
• 60 lbs → 5 treats
• 80 lbs → 6 treats
• 100 lbs → 7 treats
• 120 lbs → 8 treats

From my view, following this guide makes a big difference. My dogs still feel spoiled, but I don’t stress about overfeeding. It’s like giving dessert in the right size—enough to enjoy, not enough to weigh them down.

What Could Be Better: Hill’s Natural Training Treats

Even though my experience is good, there are a few small things that could be better. These are not deal-breakers, but they’d make the treats even stronger.

• Softness – Hill’s Soft & Chewy Treats can feel firmer than I’d like. My senior dog still eats them, but I’d like the texture to stay soft every time.
• Bag Size – The bags are small if you use them daily for training. A larger size would help, especially with more than one dog.
• Freshness Window – They keep best for 3 weeks. That’s fine, but a resealable bag that locks in moisture would help them stay soft longer.
• Price vs. Quantity – Hill’s is premium, and the price shows it. I’m fine paying more for trust and quality, but a bigger bag would feel fairer.
• Flavor Variety – Peanut butter and banana are great. Still, more natural flavors would give dogs a change of pace.

For me, these are more like a wishlist than real problems. Hill’s still gives me what matters most—nutrition, trust, and taste.

Is Hill’s Natural Soft Savories Dog Food Good?

When I first tried Hill’s Natural Soft Savories Peanut Butter and Banana, I wasn’t sure my dogs would like them. They were softer than the crunchy biscuits we used before. I was curious if that would be a win.

Over time, I’ve found Hill’s Soft Savories hit a nice balance. They mix fun flavors with good nutrition. For me, the best sign is how my dogs react. They get excited the moment I grab the bag. These treats are now part of our routine—like a morning coffee for me, but in treat form for them.

I like that they’re not empty calories. They use real ingredients that give me peace of mind. I’d call them snacks, not meals, but they pair well with Hill’s food. Together, the brand feels like a full package.

Pros and Cons of Hills Natural Soft Savories Dog Food

I’ve had enough time with these treats to see both the bright spots and the little quirks. Nothing here would stop me from using them, but I think it’s fair to share the full picture.

Pros

• Made with real ingredients like peanut butter and bananas, not fillers.
• Vet-trusted brand that gives me confidence in what I’m feeding.
• Soft texture (at least most of the time) makes them easier to use for training.
• Dogs love the flavor and look forward to snack time.
• Pairs well with other Hill’s natural dog food options for a balanced routine.

Cons

• Texture can be a little inconsistent—sometimes softer, sometimes firmer.
• The bag size feels small for the price, especially for multiple dogs.
• Best if eaten within a few weeks, or they dry out quicker than I’d like.
• Limited flavor options compared to other treat brands.

Even with those small cons, I find the pros far outweigh them. At the end of the day, these treats feel like a healthy, happy choice that my dogs enjoy and I can trust.

Alternative Option: Rachael Ray Nutrish Dish Dog Food

Over the years, I’ve tried many brands with my dogs. I always look for the right mix of nutrition, taste, and value. While Hill’s Natural Soft Savories dog food has been great, I also tested Rachael Ray Nutrish Dish dog food. Both have strengths, but they serve different needs depending on your pup.

Nutrish Dish Dog Food vs. Hill’s Natural Soft Savories

When I first tried Nutrish Dish, it looked different from normal kibble. You can see bits of dried veggies, which made me feel like it was closer to real food. With Hill’s Natural Soft Savories, I liked the soft, chewy feel. They were perfect for training and quick rewards.

In short, Hill’s treats shine for training. Nutrish Dish stands out as a daily meal with visible, wholesome pieces.

Nutrish Dish Dog Food vs. Hill’s Natural Dog Food

From my own tests, Nutrish Dish reviews were right—dogs like the taste. The real veggie bits give owners extra confidence. On the other side, Hill’s Natural Dog Food reviews highlight steady nutrition backed by science.

My takeaway: Hill’s brings peace of mind with research-led meals. Nutrish adds charm with a homemade feel and a cause that helps pets.

Rachael Ray Chicken Dog Food vs. Hill’s Natural Soft Savories

When I compared Rachael Ray Chicken Dog Food with Hill’s treats, the gap was clear. Nutrish is made for full meals. Hill’s Soft Savories are designed for fun, rewards, and bonding.

Both fill a role. Hill’s works best for treats. Rachael Ray’s chicken recipe fits as a full meal.

Final Word on Alternatives

Both brands earn a place. Hill’s Natural Soft Savories are my top choice for training and bonding. Rachael Ray Nutrish Dish gives a balanced, wholesome meal that looks and tastes like real food.

My Final Thoughts on Hill’s Natural Soft Savories

If you want soft treats that double as training rewards, Hill’s Natural Soft Savories are a solid pick. They blend taste and nutrition in each bite. But if you’re looking for a daily meal, you may want to explore other foods. For me, these treats turned training into bonding time—and that is priceless.

FAQs about Hills Natural Soft Savories Dog Food

• Is Hills Natural Soft Savories dog food good for training?
  Yes. It’s soft, chewy, and easy to break into small pieces. That makes it perfect for rewarding good behavior during training.
• Can Hills Natural Soft Savories dog food be a meal replacement?
  No. These are treats, not full meals. They should only make up about 10% of your dog’s daily diet.
• What flavors do Hills Natural Soft Savories dog food treats come in?
  They come in fun flavors like peanut butter with banana and chicken with yogurt. These are tasty options, even for picky eaters.
• Are Hills Natural Soft Savories dog food treats safe for all dogs?
  Yes. They are made with natural ingredients. But if your pup has allergies, it’s best to check with your vet first.
• How long do Hills Natural Soft Savories dog food treats last after opening?
  To keep them soft and tasty, use them within 3 weeks after opening.

Where to Buy Soft Savories Dog Food

Finding Soft Savories has been easy for me. I’ve bought them both online and in local pet stores without trouble. Shopping online feels simpler because I can compare prices and read reviews. For me, buying online also saved time and kept my dog’s treat jar full.

Soft Savories Dog Food Recall

Safety is always on my mind when picking food or treats for my dog. Over the years, Soft Savories has had very few recalls compared to other brands. That gave me peace of mind. Still, I always check news or official sources before buying. It’s a small habit, but it helps me feel sure I’m giving my pup something safe and trustworthy.

Taslima Akter Sumaiya

Taslima Akter Sumaiya is a passionate pet mom and founder of PetFoodHubing.com. With real-life experience and insights inspired by USDA-ARS experts like Dr. Jitender P. Dubey, she writes honest, research-backed reviews to help dog and cat parents choose the best food. Trust her to simplify pet nutrition—with love and science. Read More…