Merrick vs Orijen Dog Food: Attractive, Stunning Verdict

If you want a quick answer to Merrick vs Orijen Dog Food, both brands are strong, but they serve dogs with different needs. I have used both, and I’ve seen how each one helps in its own way. I like to share what works in real homes here in the US, where dogs have busy lives and many food options. Let me guide you with what I’ve learned so you can pick the one that feels right for your dog.

Table of Contents

Merrick Dog Food Review

I’ve been using Merrick dog food for a while now, and this review comes from real-life experience. I’ll keep it simple, clear, and honest.

Is Merrick Dog Food Good?

Yes, Merrick dog food is good, especially if you want real meat and clean ingredients. I tried Merrick because I wanted food with better protein and fewer fillers. My puppy reacted well to it at first. The kibble smelled fresh, and he ate it with no hesitation. I liked that Merrick uses real deboned meat as the first ingredient. It felt like a safer choice compared to many big-brand options.

From what I’ve seen, the protein and ingredients do stand out. You get deboned beef, chicken, salmon, or lamb. You also get sweet potatoes, fruits, veggies, and added nutrients like omega-3, omega-6, glucosamine, and chondroitin sulfate. These helped keep my dog’s coat soft and his joints strong as he grew.

Merrick’s ingredient focus is simple: real meat first, then supportive ingredients for fiber, digestion, and overall health. I have used both their Grain-Free and Healthy Grains lines. Both felt balanced and worked well day-to-day.

But—not every bag is perfect. I once bought a bag online, and that batch didn’t sit well with my puppy. He got constipated. I couldn’t return it, which was frustrating. That’s when I became more aware of potential concerns, like past recalls and a class-action lawsuit over “natural” claims. Merrick also shows up in conversations about grain-free diets and possible links to DCM. This does not mean the food is unsafe, but it’s something I keep in mind.

Still, I like their ingredient philosophy. They push for whole, natural, high-quality foods. They say they source ingredients from trusted farmers and ranchers in the USA, and that lines up with what I’ve seen so far. But, like many brands, there has been controversy—recalls, lawsuits, and some buyer complaints about quality.

In Short:

Merrick offers solid formulations, both grain-free and with healthy grains. When the batch is good, it performs well. My dog’s energy stays high. His coat looks nice. His digestion stays stable.

What I Like

Real meat first. I like that the food starts with real deboned beef, chicken, or salmon. My dog reacts well to higher-quality protein. His muscle tone stays strong, and he loves the taste.

Good mix of nutrients. The added omega fatty acids, glucosamine, and chondroitin helped with skin health and joint strength as my puppy grew. I noticed smoother movement and better coat shine.

Flexible formulas. I used both Grain-Free and Healthy Grains. They worked well for daily feeding. The grain-inclusive line felt better for long-term use and digestion, based on my experience.

What Could Be Better

Batch consistency. Not every bag feels the same. One bag made my puppy constipated. That made me more cautious with online orders.

Recall history. Past recalls and lawsuits make me double-check labels and sourcing. It doesn’t mean the food is bad, but it does make me more aware.

Price. Merrick is not cheap. For a mid-premium brand, the cost can feel high, especially for big dogs or multi-dog homes.

Quick Overview of Merrick

Here is a fast look at Merrick. This helps you see if it fits what your dog needs.

Feature	What It Means
Lots of real meat	Meat is first
Grain-free and grain-included lines	You can pick what works best
Many protein options	Chicken, beef, turkey, lamb, fish
High-calorie and high-fat	Rich and dense food

Recommendation

I recommend Merrick if you want real meat first, clean ingredients, and good nutritional support. It works well for puppies and adult dogs. The nutrients help with coat health, joints, and overall energy. If you live in the USA, the “crafted in the USA” part may give you more peace of mind about sourcing.

But if your dog has a very sensitive stomach, check how they react in the first week. And if you’re worried about grain-free diets or the recall history, you may want to choose Merrick’s Healthy Grains line or compare it with another brand before buying.

For most owners, Merrick is a solid choice. Just watch your dog’s digestion and buy from a seller you trust.

Orijen Dog Food Review

My real-life experience with Orijen shows how strong the food can be for active dogs, but it also taught me where it may not fit every pup.

Is Orijen Dog Food Good?

Yes, Orijen dog food is good if you want high protein and rich ingredients. In my experience, it works well for dogs that need strong muscle support and do well on meat-heavy diets. I used Orijen Original dry dog food for a long stretch. I saw better energy and a shiny coat. My dog stayed lean and active. The food felt fresh and clean, and it had that “real meat” smell that told me the formula was not bland or filler-heavy.

Orijen uses a “Biologically Appropriate” mix built on WholePrey ideas. That means it leans on fresh or raw meat, organs, and bone. The protein level is high, and the food hits hard when it comes to meat density. I liked that. It made me feel like I was feeding something close to what dogs ate before they were pets.

But I learned one thing fast. A protein level this high is not for every dog. My dog handled it well, but I have talked with owners whose dogs had soft stools. Some saw tummy issues when switching too fast. This depends on the dog. If your dog is sensitive, you may need to ease into it.

Orijen has great points, but it also has a few concerns. The brand faced lawsuits over heavy metals and BPA claims. It was also part of the FDA’s DCM review. And after Mars bought Champion Petfoods in 2022, some US dog owners worried about possible formula changes. I have not seen a clear change yet, but I watch labels now, just to stay safe.