Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals: Remarkable Expert Review
Choosing between Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals can feel tricky since both promise real meat and probiotics. From my own use, I’ve seen Taste of the Wild shine for dogs with food needs, while Diamond Naturals delivers solid nutrition at a lower cost. After testing both, I can say each has strengths worth noting. Let’s break them down so you can pick the right fit for your pup.
Is Taste of the Wild Dog Food Good?
Yes — in my experience, Taste of the Wild is a solid choice if you want a natural, grain-free diet for your dog with real meat or fish as the first ingredient.
When I first switched to this food, I noticed my dog’s coat became shinier within a few weeks. The formula uses spring-fed trout, bison, salmon, or venison, depending on the variety, all paired with species-specific K9 Strain® probiotics to support gut health.
I also like how it avoids fillers like corn or wheat. The ingredient list is short, clean, and focused on real nutrition. The inclusion of prebiotics, probiotics, and antioxidants from fruits and vegetables helps keep digestion smooth and immunity strong.
It’s a premium food that fits dogs with grain sensitivities or owners who prefer novel protein sources like bison or duck. It’s not cheap, but the quality and digestibility make it worth the price.
What I Like
- Real meat first: Every recipe I’ve tried starts with real meat or fish — trout, bison, salmon, or venison. My dog always seems excited at mealtime, which says a lot about its flavor and freshness.
- Probiotics that work: I noticed better digestion and firmer stools after a week. The K9 Strain® probiotics are clearly doing their job.
- High digestibility: Even with rich proteins like duck or venison, my dog didn’t have stomach upset. The mix of sweet potatoes, lentils, and legumes makes it easy on the stomach.
- Great coat and energy: The omega fatty acids and salmon oil made a visible difference. My dog’s coat looks healthier, and his energy levels are consistent throughout the day.
- Variety of flavors: I like that they offer many protein options — great for picky eaters or dogs with food allergies.
- Widely available: Easy to find across the US, both online (Amazon, Chewy, PetSmart) and in most pet stores.
What Could Be Better
- Price: It’s on the higher side compared to many mid-range brands. While the ingredients justify it, it might not fit every budget.
- Limited scientific research: The formulas are balanced and nutrient-rich, but there’s limited direct scientific backing for the brand’s claims beyond general pet nutrition standards.
- Occasional recalls: There was a voluntary recall in 2012 for possible Salmonella contamination. No major issues since then, but it’s something to be aware of.
- Packaging: The resealable bags don’t always hold up well, especially in humid climates — I recommend using an airtight container.
Recommendation
If your dog has a sensitive stomach, grain allergies, or you just want a premium, high-protein diet, Taste of the Wild is a great choice.
I’d especially recommend it for:
- Dogs with grain sensitivities or skin issues
- Owners seeking novel protein sources (bison, venison, duck)
- Those who prefer clean, natural formulations without unnecessary fillers
However, if you’re on a tight budget or prefer a brand with more published scientific studies, you might compare it with Diamond Naturals, which comes from the same parent company — Diamond Pet Foods — but offers more affordable options.
In short, Taste of the Wild delivers on flavor, quality, and digestibility. It feels like feeding your dog something closer to their ancestral diet — simple, clean, and packed with real nutrition.
Is Diamond Naturals Dog Food Good?
Yes — in my view, Diamond Naturals dog food is a smart pick. It gives dogs good nutrition at a fair price. It’s simple, healthy, and easy to feed.
I began using Diamond Naturals when my dog’s coat looked dull and his stomach was upset. After a few weeks, I saw a clear change. His fur looked bright, and his tummy settled down. The mix of real meat, probiotics, and omega oils seemed to help right away.
This brand does not use cheap fillers or fake colors. It has real meat, rice or barley, fruits, and veggies that make a balanced meal. The K9 Strain Probiotics also help with gut health. I found this useful for dogs that have sensitive stomachs or mild allergies.
What I Like
- Real ingredients for a fair price
From my use, Diamond Naturals gives great value. It uses real meat, fruits, and veggies, not by-products or corn. I like knowing my dog gets clean food without paying luxury prices.- Better coat and digestion
The K9 Strain Probiotics work well. My dog’s digestion was smoother, and his stool looked better in a week. The omega fats from flaxseed and coconut made his coat soft and shiny.- Dogs enjoy the taste
My dog loves the flavor, mostly chicken and lamb. Even picky eaters seem to like it. I don’t need to mix wet food to tempt him.- Easy to find in the U.S.
You can buy it on Amazon, Chewy, or Tractor Supply, or at most pet stores. I never worry about stock or long shipping times.
What Could Be Better
- Older recall history
Diamond Pet Foods had recalls in 2012 and 2015 for Salmonella. None have happened since, but it’s wise to stay alert for news.- Few grain-inclusive choices
Some recipes are grain-free. I wish they had more with whole grains for owners who avoid grain-free diets.- Low vitamin E levels
The food supports coat health, but adding a bit more vitamin E could improve antioxidant support, mainly for older or active dogs.
Recommendation
If you want natural dog food that fits a budget, Diamond Naturals is worth it. It works well for dogs with mild skin, coat, or stomach issues.
I suggest it for:
- Owners who want real meat and probiotics in daily meals.
- Dogs that need help with digestion or coat shine.
- Buyers in the U.S. who like family-owned, local brands.
If your dog has serious allergies or heart problems, talk to your vet first or choose the grain-inclusive line.
Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals: Detailed Comparison
I’ve tried both Taste of the Wild and Diamond Naturals with my dog. Each promises real meat, added probiotics, and steady nutrition. Both work well but in different ways. Here’s my full take to help you find which one fits your pup best.
Specifications
Both aim to support dogs’ health. One feels more premium. The other is more budget-friendly.
| Brand | Formula Type | Grain Options | Recall History | Target Market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Premium, grain-free | Grain-free, some ancient grains | 2012 recall | Owners seeking novel proteins |
| Diamond Naturals | Value, natural | Grain + grain-free | 2012, 2015 recalls | Families wanting balance |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Decode the Kibble: A Tasty Truth for Every Tail-Wagger
Taste matters. Dogs speak with their bowls.
| Brand | Taste Appeal | Variety | Dog Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Very high | Bison, trout, salmon, venison | Excited eaters |
| Diamond Naturals | Good | Chicken, lamb, salmon, beef | Well accepted |
- Taste of the Wild: 9/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8.5/10
Design & Composition
The two brands follow different paths in design.
| Brand | Style | Notable Traits |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Limited, grain-free | Novel proteins, clean mix |
| Diamond Naturals | Balanced, inclusive | Superfoods, whole grains |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Ingredient Highlights & Nutrient Breakdown (Quick View)
What’s inside matters most.
| Brand | First Ingredient | Key Extras |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Meat or fish | Probiotics, omega oils |
| Diamond Naturals | Real meat | Superfoods, probiotics |
- Taste of the Wild: 9/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8.5/10
Digestive Health Match-Up: Gentle Nutrition Compared
Digestive health can make or break a diet.
| Brand | Probiotics | Prebiotics | Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | K9 Strain® probiotics | Legume fiber | Firm stools, fewer upsets |
| Diamond Naturals | Higher count | Whole grains, chia | Smooth digestion |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 9/10
Features
Both stand out for unique reasons.
| Brand | Highlights |
|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Grain-free focus, novel meats, premium feel |
| Diamond Naturals | Budget value, superfoods, probiotics |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Performance
Real-life results matter more than any label.
| Brand | Coat & Skin | Energy | Stomach Health |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Shinier coat, steady energy | Great | Good for sensitive dogs |
| Diamond Naturals | Shiny coat, stable energy | Good | Strong gut support |
- Taste of the Wild: 9/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8.5/10
Guaranteed Analysis
Here’s a quick glance at the basics.
| Brand | Protein | Fat | Fiber | Moisture |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | 27% | 15% | 5% | 10% |
| Diamond Naturals | 25% | 14% | 5% | 10% |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Protein Content Analysis: Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals
Protein builds muscle and fuels play.
| Brand | Protein % | Main Sources |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | 27% | Bison, trout, venison, salmon |
| Diamond Naturals | 25% | Chicken, lamb, salmon |
- Taste of the Wild: 9/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Fat Content Analysis: Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals
Fat adds flavor and keeps coats shiny.
| Brand | Fat % | Sources |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | 15% | Salmon oil, sunflower oil |
| Diamond Naturals | 14% | Flaxseed, coconut oil |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Pricing & Availability
Price and access both count.
| Brand | Avg Price (30lb) | Where to Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | $55–$65 | Online, pet stores |
| Diamond Naturals | $40–$50 | Online, farm/pet stores |
- Taste of the Wild: 8/10
- Diamond Naturals: 9/10
User Experience
What other dog parents say.
| Brand | Feedback | Ease of Use |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Great taste, shiny coat | Bags can rip |
| Diamond Naturals | Good for price, helps digestion | Easy to buy |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8.5/10
Price vs Nutrition: Taste of the Wild and Alternative Options
It’s all about balance.
| Brand | Value | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Premium, higher cost | Dogs with food needs |
| Diamond Naturals | Strong value | Families on a budget |
- Taste of the Wild: 8/10
- Diamond Naturals: 9/10
Ecosystem & Brand Context
Both share one parent company.
| Brand | Parent | Focus | Reputation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Diamond Pet Foods | Premium, ancestral diets | Well trusted |
| Diamond Naturals | Diamond Pet Foods | Affordable natural food | Popular, trusted |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Pros & Cons: Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals
| Brand | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Premium meats, grain-free, shiny coat | Higher cost, fewer grain-inclusive options |
| Diamond Naturals | Low cost, probiotics, solid nutrition | Past recalls, less novel meats |
- Taste of the Wild: 8.5/10
- Diamond Naturals: 8/10
Verdict / Summary: Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals
Both brands shine, but in different ways.
| Brand | Best For | Final Score |
|---|---|---|
| Taste of the Wild | Sensitive dogs, premium diets | 8.5/10 |
| Diamond Naturals | Budget-friendly, solid nutrition | 8.5/10 |
My take: Taste of the Wild works best for dogs with food needs or picky eaters. Diamond Naturals fits families who want good food at a fair cost. Both bring value — just in their own style.
FAQs for Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals
What are the main differences between Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals?
Taste of the Wild is premium with novel proteins and grain-free focus. Diamond Naturals is budget-friendly with balanced, natural recipes.
Which is better for dogs with food sensitivities?
Taste of the Wild works better for sensitive dogs due to novel meats and grain-free options. Diamond Naturals is mild but less allergy-focused.
How do prices compare for Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals?
Taste of the Wild is higher priced, around $55–$65 per 30lb bag. Diamond Naturals costs less, about $40–$50, making it easier on budgets.
Which brand offers more variety in flavors?
Taste of the Wild has unique proteins like bison, trout, and venison. Diamond Naturals sticks with common flavors such as chicken, lamb, and salmon.
Are both brands safe and reliable long term?
Both brands are made by Diamond Pet Foods. Each had recalls in the past, but safety steps have improved. Many dog owners trust them today.
Where to Buy Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals Dog Food
Finding the right dog food can feel like looking for that missing puzzle piece that finally fits. Luckily, both Taste of the Wild and Diamond Naturals are easy to find in many trusted stores.
I’ve bought Taste of the Wild several times from PetSmart and Petco. It’s also easy to order online from Amazon, Chewy, or the brand’s own site. Buying online often gives you better deals, especially if you use auto-ship. It feels great when the food shows up at your door just as the old bag runs out.
Diamond Naturals is just as simple to find. It’s sold at Tractor Supply Co., Chewy, Amazon, and many local pet stores that carry quality but affordable food. I’ve noticed that Diamond Naturals often costs a little less per pound. That helps a lot if you have a large breed or more than one dog to feed.
If you like shopping in person, always check the bag’s freshness date and condition. I once found a bag that seemed a bit stale after sitting on a shelf too long. Since then, I always look at the packaging date printed near the barcode. It’s a small habit that saves headaches later.
Both brands also have handy store locators on their websites. I love that feature. It makes life easier when you’re in a hurry or just want to find the closest retailer.
In short, you won’t have trouble finding either brand. It’s like choosing between two trusted grocery stores—you’ll get what you need wherever you shop.
Taste of the Wild vs Diamond Naturals Recall History
When it comes to dog food, honesty and safety matter as much as taste. Both Taste of the Wild and Diamond Naturals are made by Diamond Pet Foods, so their recall history is shared. That’s something I always check before feeding my dogs any brand.
In 2012, Diamond Pet Foods had a voluntary recall because of possible salmonella at one of their plants. It affected several product lines, including Taste of the Wild. While that caused concern back then, the company reacted fast. They cleaned the facility, improved testing, and tightened safety steps.
Since then, Taste of the Wild has had no major recalls. That gives me peace of mind. They now test every batch before it leaves the plant, which shows they learned from past mistakes.
Diamond Naturals also had a few recalls long ago for possible contamination or formula imbalances, with the last big one also in 2012. Thankfully, there have been no major problems in recent years. It seems they’ve worked hard to improve quality control.
Still, no brand is perfect. Making dog food is a bit like cooking for a big family—one small slip can spoil the meal. What counts most is how a company reacts. From what I’ve seen, both brands took the right steps and earned back trust by staying open and careful.
If you’re like me and like to stay informed, check the FDA recall page once in a while. It’s a smart habit—like glancing at your dog’s bowl to make sure the food looks and smells right.
Overall, both brands had their rough patches years ago, but they’ve grown stronger. They’ve shown care, honesty, and improvement over time. I still feed them with confidence, knowing they’ve turned lessons into lasting safety.
Taslima Akter Sumaiya is a passionate pet mom and founder of PetFoodHubing.com. With real-life experience and insights inspired by USDA-ARS experts like Dr. Jitender P. Dubey, she writes honest, research-backed reviews to help dog and cat parents choose the best food. Trust her to simplify pet nutrition—with love and science. Read More…
